Testimony · May 14, 2025

Justice-Involved Youth in Community Act Roundtable

Joshua Miller · Open City Advocates

LegislationPublic safety

Public Roundtable on the Justice-Involved Youth in Community Act of 2025
Committee on Youth Affairs, Council of the District of Columbia
Councilmember Zachary Parker, Chairperson

May 14, 2025

Testimony of Joshua A. Miller, PhD, Research & Advocacy Director

Who We Are

Open City Advocates is a small organization with a big impact. We model an innovative solution in juvenile defense in Washington, DC, and nationwide. Founded to address the racial inequities and unjust incarceration practices in DC’s juvenile system, Open City Advocates provides youth-centered legal defense and holistic advocacy for young people after sentencing in the juvenile system.

Who We Serve

All of our clients have been committed to the care and custody of the DC Department of Youth Rehabilitation Services (DYRS) by DC’s Family Court. “Commitment” to DYRS means that a young person is a ward of the city, oftentimes until age 21, and that their placement may change several times with little or no court oversight—including placement at home or in a carceral facility.

There are extreme racial disparities in the youth delinquency system nationwide, with Black and Latino/a children being committed and incarcerated at 4.7 times the rate compared to their white peers.¹ It is even more extreme in the District of Columbia, where 100% of all committed children are children of color, and 96% are Black, while Black youth comprise only 51% of the DC youth population.²

Open City Advocates’ clients have had extensive contact with the delinquency system; most have also been in DC’s child welfare system, and all are at high risk for entering the DC Jail or being harmed or killed by street violence. The majority of our clients hail from DC’s Wards 7 and 8, where 35% of children live in poverty.³ Over the last two years, 46% of violent crimes committed with guns in the city occurred in these two wards.⁴ In our 20-year history, we have lost six clients to gun violence and one to a drug overdose. Open City Advocates works to help our clients envision and actualize a healthy adulthood instead of accepting death or incarceration by age 25.

The Justice-Involved Youth in Community Act of 2025

Good morning, Chairperson Parker and members of the committee. My name is Joshua Miller, I am the Research & Advocacy Director at Open City Advocates, which provides legal representation, holistic advocacy, and mentoring to youth who have been committed to the DC Department of Youth Rehabilitation Services or DYRS.

My colleague Whitney Louchheim previously testified before the Committee on Public Safety and the Judiciary on this bill, and I endorse all of her detailed discussion and the research that she shared. Our primary concerns with this bill are threefold: 1) it creates a third-party monitor, known as a “Trusted Adult,” who is charged with revoking deferred disposition and deferred prosecution agreements, despite the fact that this role is already adequately filled by the Office of the Attorney General and the officers from the Superior Court’s Court Social Services Division, 2) it presents this monitor as a “mentor” who will also ensure the provision of needed services, despite monitoring and mentoring being diametrically opposed roles, 3) it places pseudo-mentees in a position where revocation is likely to undermine the benefits of mentorship and indeed create feelings of self-blame and abandonment.

By way of extending that analysis, I want to discuss the tension in the term “Trusted Adult” in this context. Creating stricter standards for alternative prosecution tools appears to be a policy in search of a problem to solve, but the overall emphasis on mentoring is novel and indeed laudatory. While the term has many different usages, the National Alliance on Mental Illness defines a “Trusted Adult” as someone who offers support, encouragement, and a role model for action, someone who “talks, rather than tells,” and someone who acts as a neutral part of a child’s safety network, all of which is at odds with the pseudo-supervisory role envisioned by this bill.⁵

Research about mentoring best practices suggests that a punitive approach to mentoring doesn’t work, and can indeed backfire. In the largest metastudy to date on the use of mentoring in the juvenile justice context, the data showed that the most successful programs paired mentors with mentees for more than a year, used careful closures processes, and encouraged mentors to advocate on behalf of their mentees. Mentors have to be allowed to be fully partisan–taking their mentee’s side–because an unconditionally supportive adult is what every flourishing child has in their lives, and what we owe to children who encounter the abuse, neglect, and delinquency systems. We shouldn’t be subjecting children to additional adverse childhood experiences as a part of a process that is supposed to be “trauma-informed.”

We already lack adequate mentoring services in the city, and it would be better not to co-opt that role with additional surveillance that will increase the number of children in the institutional end of the system. I want to be clear that the idea of mentors for youth at this stage isn’t bad, though it may not be the place where we need the most intervention in the system. It’s only the dual mandate of support and surveillance that makes this “Trusted Adult” potentially detrimental.

As OAG’s Erin Cullen has testified and clarified, in FY23, 33% of these agreements were revoked under the current system.⁶ A 33% revocation rate is high, and we should work to decrease it, in the same way that we’d address deficiencies in a school context: providing resources and support, rather than additional threats of punishment. But this bill appears poised to do the opposite.

Thank you for the opportunity to testify regarding this bill. I’m available to answer questions.

Previously-delivered testimony

The letter introducing the Justice-Involved Youth in Community Act of 2025 suggests that the “Trusted Adults” are intended to act as mentors, yet in the text of the bill they are empowered to judge compliance and to punish noncompliance with these agreements in a way that reads closer to “monitoring” than mentoring.

Research about mentoring best practices suggests that a punitive approach to mentoring doesn’t work, and can indeed backfire. Now, to be clear, the evidence shows that mentoring for high-risk youth has a positive effect for delinquency and aggression. Indeed, numerous high quality studies have identified best practices that, when followed, significantly enhance a program’s effectiveness. Some of these best practices include:

  1. targeting youth who have already exhibited delinquent behavior,
  2. serving a high proportion of males,
  3. providing ongoing and timely emotional support to the mentors and mentees,
  4. recruiting mentors from targeted sources to create “a good fit between the educational or occupational backgrounds of mentors and the goals of the program,”
  5. matching mentoring pairs based on shared interests, and
  6. providing a structure through which mentors can advocate on behalf of their mentees.

Importantly, programs that include more than six best practices have twice the impact of programs with fewer best practices.⁷

Mentoring programs that had an advocacy role for the mentors had effect sizes three times larger than programs that did not include an advocacy role for the mentors. Of all the various mediating factors that mentoring programs included, an advocacy role had by far the most significant effect on a program’s effectiveness in terms of youth outcomes.⁸

Over the years, our organization has incorporated all six best practices listed above. We have also implemented the fundamental best practices for mentoring, based on the National Mentoring Partnership’s Elements of Effective Practice for Mentoring, such as intensive screening of volunteers, thorough initial and in-service training, and ongoing mentor support.

In order to ensure that mentoring programs are implemented in keeping with these best practices, it’s important to train staff and mentors on service delivery and data collection regularly, using external trainers who are experts in the Positive Youth Development model, and to analyze both intermediate data like case reports and outcomes quarterly and annually to ensure compliance and validity. It’s also important to ensure that mentoring pairs are given an opportunity to extend beyond one year, as that has been shown to be the time period over which the benefits of mentorship become concrete. Shorter periods of mentorship are not only less effective but can even be harmful,⁹ and indeed it’s important that formal mentoring programs prepare participants for the eventual end of those relationships, using a closure process that ensures that youth do not feel rejection or self-blame.¹⁰

The Trusted Adults described in this bill appear to be perfect candidates for the kind of mentoring that turns out to be ineffective or, even worse, harmful. Assigned alongside a probation officer, with the power and responsibility to monitor compliance and punish noncompliance by sending the child into detention, this is the opposite of the advocacy role described in the best practices, not to mention the importance of voluntariness and matches based on personal interests. The Trusted Adult “monitorship” relationship will then end abruptly, and in cases of noncompliance, in a way that lays the blame at the child’s feet—a recipe for psychological harm. We can and must do better by our young people.

We have seen this type of compliance “monitorship” before. For several years around 2010-2014, DYRS employed “third party monitors” to track youths’ compliance with curfew and other requirements. These were not “trusted adults” in the eyes of either youth or families precisely because they were tasked with reporting on the youths’ compliance with DYRS requirements. When a trusting relationship did develop, some monitors would then falsify the compliance documentation in order to maintain the trusting relationship. This program was discontinued—almost certainly because it suffered from this incompatibility between being a trusted adult and simultaneously reporting on a young person’s compliance.

If there are any simple takeaways, it should be these: young people involved in the juvenile system benefit from mentors, but only when those mentors are matched voluntarily, have an advocacy role (the opposite of a reporting role), and when the relationship lasts more than a year.

Notes

  1. OJJDP Census of Juveniles in Residential Placement.
  2. DYRS Demographics, https://dataviz1.dc.gov/t/OCTO/views/PublicSafety/YouthDemographics; DC Kids Count, 2023.
  3. DC Kids Count, 2023.
  4. See crimecards.dc.gov.
  5. See “Be a Trusted Adult for Young People in Your Life” available here: https://www.nami.org/your-journey/kids-teens-and-young-adults/youth-and-young-adult-resources/be-a-trusted-adult-for-young-people-in-your-life/
  6. 315 of the 1091 open matters led to an alternative prosecutorial tool: a Consent Decree, a Deferred Prosecution Agreement, or a Deferred Disposition Agreement. Of those, 210 young people successfully completed their agreement, and 105 of the agreements were revoked. Of those 105, 77 were given probation, 19 were committed, and 10 more were either dismissed (including after successful completion of HOPE Court or a behavioral diversion program) or were still pending.
  7. DuBois, D. L., Holloway, B. E., Valentine, J. C., & Cooper, H., “Effectiveness of Mentoring Programs for Youth: A Meta-Analytic Review,” American Journal of Community Psychology, 30(2), 157-197; 2002.
  8. Tolan, P., Henry, D., Schoeny, M., Bass, A., Lovegrove, P., and Nichols, E., Mentoring Interventions to Affect Juvenile Delinquency and Associated Problems: A Systematic Review. Campbell Systematic Reviews (2013), 8.
  9. Grossman, J. B., & Rhodes, J. E. (2002). “The test of time: Predictors and effects of duration in youth mentoring relationships.” American Journal of Community Psychology, 30(2), 199–219.
  10. See: Kupersmidt, J. B., Stump, K. N., Stelter, R. L., & Rhodes, J. E. (2017). Predictors of Premature Match Closure in Youth Mentoring Relationships. American Journal of Community Psychology, 59(1-2), 44–55. See also Spencer, R., & Basualdo-Delmonico, A. (2014). Termination and closure of mentoring relationships. In D. L. DuBois & M. J. Karcher (Eds.), Handbook of youth mentoring (2nd ed., pp. 319–331). Sage Publications, Inc.

Free to quote and share with attribution.