Testimony · Apr 25, 2024
Office of the Ombudsperson for Children (OFC)
Joshua Miller · Open City Advocates
Budget Oversight Hearing
Office of the Ombudsperson for Children
April 25, 2024
Committee on Facilities and Family Services
Ward 4 Councilmember Janeese Lewis George, Chairperson
Testimony of Joshua A. Miller, PhD
Research & Advocacy Director, Open City Advocates
Good morning. My name is Joshua Miller, I am a resident of Ward 4 and Research & Advocacy Director for Open City Advocates, which provides legal representation and holistic advocacy to youth who have been committed to DYRS.
For many years and in many settings, Open City Advocates has been arguing for the unification of oversight over the two state agencies who take children into their custody to include a mechanism for the investigation and adjudication of complaints by children under the care of CFSA and those committed to DYRS and their families. Ironically, the proposed budget offers both to eliminate the Ombudsperson for Children and to shrink the Office of Independent Juvenile Justice Facilities Oversight, which was charged with ensuring compliance with the Jerry M. consent decree after DYRS facilities were found to be grossly unsafe. (Notably DYRS no longer complies with many of the consent decree’s provisions.) While the revenue forecast is difficult, we must not respond to difficult times by withdrawing oversight and protection for young people.
In many states, the neglect and delinquency agencies work closely together under shared oversight. This is because these states recognize the parallels between neglect and delinquency, and that most young people committed to the juvenile rehabilitation agencies have multiple adverse childhood experiences including abuse, and that most cases of delinquency are not personal failures on the part of the child requiring accountability, but rather are tied to systemic failures by adults to support children’s needs. Many children committed to DYRS who do not have a CFSA case file are nonetheless “crossover youth” according to this principle.
We regularly notice a lack of coordination between CFSA and DYRS around crossover youth. In a time of tight budgets, cost-shifting is inevitable, but asking young people to navigate bureaucratic comedies of responsibility-shifting is a tragedy. Children ought to be playing hot potato or musical chairs with their friends, not be treated like those toys.
Nationwide, crossover youth suffer more severe consequences in the juvenile justice system and experience poorer long-term outcomes. There is little data about crossover youth in DC and there are few effective formal procedures outlining how CFSA and DYRS work with crossover youth. A dual-agency ombudsperson would encourage data collection, facilitate collaboration, enable greater family engagement, and work to disrupt the pathway from foster care to juvenile delinquency.
Expanding the authority of the Office of the Ombudsperson for Children to cover committed youth would allow the office to serve a dual purpose: investigating and resolving individual complaints from youth and families, and monitoring systemic practices in order to encourage reforms. In order to effectively investigate and mediate complaints from families, the ombudsperson must be an independent, neutral body, not subject to supervision by CFSA or DYRS. The ombudsperson should also collect and evaluate data from DYRS to identify gaps in service provision and recommend improvements to daily practices. In the very best case scenario, this would also significantly implicate children’s experience in in-patient care in DBH facilities and contractors.
A budget oversight hearing may not seem like the best moment to dream big. But as we watch the proposed budget threaten to zero out the office whose hard work we still hope to build on, I think it is important to imagine clearly what it needs to become to keep our children safe and their families confident in their treatment.
Thank you for your time. I’m available to answer any questions.
Free to quote and share with attribution.